John C. Reilly made his first indelible impression upon moviegoers in the 1999 cult classic “Magnolia,” in which his sensitive loner Catholic policeman Jim Kurring was the quiet center of a maelstrom of characters suffering from emotional crises across Los Angeles. 

Seeing him kneel peacefully before a crucifix in the opening moments, while other characters dealt with crippling depression, drug addictions, and sexual abuse set the stage for him as the kindest character, with the most dramatically positive effect in the movie’s large cast.

He’s played lovable losers and relatable everymen in dozens of films since then, showing surprising range — he scored an Oscar nomination for his turn as the cuckolded Amos Hart in the musical “Chicago” and played the fool with Will Ferrell in a trio of outrageous comedies, including the sublimely stupid “Step Brothers.”

Yet he has always loved performing live theatre the most, because of the immediacy and intimate connection it allows between performers and their audience— and considers it a mission driven partly by his own Catholic faith. He will be spotlighting that passion for a month onstage at the Pasadena Playhouse’s Carrie Hamilton Theatre from May 24 through June 22 with “Gather: Surprising Stories and Other Mischief.” The play brings out a team of veteran actors coming together to perform a colorful array of stories for all ages.

“We’re trying to reach out and connect with people by sharing stories in the dark. What else are we gonna do?” Reilly said. “All the problems in the world seem so intractable. All I can do is have empathy for other human beings, regardless of politics and anything else. All we have is empathy and this is built on that. We’re hoping to grow into something bigger, and take it to the larger stage at the Playhouse, to schools, other theatres and places as we grow.”

The show’s selections include Grimm’s fairy tales, classic old folk tales and other family-friendly scenes — all organized and edited by Reilly, with his longtime artistic collaborator Patrick Murphy, who was his first acting teacher in college. The pair had discussed teaming up for a story theater project since they first met, when Murphy taught Reilly’s acting class in college. Reilly believes their efforts will prove to be a powerful experience for audiences.

“The Playhouse was generous to give us this, because in this time of bad news, what else can we do but come together regardless of beliefs, and tell stories to each other?” he said. “And we’ll sing some songs because the stories are interspersed with us singing old songs you might remember. You’ll have some soul nourishment, some humor and some old-fashioned theater magic.

“It’s a really intimate space, with 99 seats, and we weave this kind of dream and tell nine or 10 different stories,” he added. “It’s really a show for young people and old, age group 8 to 800. It’s family friendly, though some stories are darker than others, so we’re thinking of adding matinees to tone down the scary bits even more for really little kids.”

A devoted family man, Reilly has been married to his wife, independent-film producer Alison Dickey, since 1992 and has two children. He grew up in a larger family in Chicago, the fifth of six children born to the owner of an industrial linen supply company business, who was also named John.

He first took the stage at eight years old, displaying a natural talent that led him to train at the Goodman School of Drama before becoming a member of the Steppenwolf Theatre, one of America’s most acclaimed dramatic institutions. Throughout his lengthy career, he has relied on his Catholic upbringing in determining what kinds of roles he will play. 

“I was raised Catholic and confirmed, and it gave me a lot growing up, including a reason to be a good person,” he said. “I’m a big fan of Pope Francis, who’s doing very Christ-like work on the issues we’re dealing with now. As a kid, I was an optimist and still am. I felt as a kid that this is a group of people coming together because they want to make the world better, love each other, shake hands, be together and not feel so lonely in the world. That’s a noble thing.

“How I was brought up definitely informs my choices, because it affected my ethical consciousness and the things that I choose to do,” he concluded. “I do feel there’s a mission in my work to try and illuminate the human experience. I do try to achieve things that I really believe in. That’s not to say I don’t play dark characters or people who are morally challenged, but I try to find work that’s a good place to live for six months. I’ve been offered things so dark and to live with that character in my mind and spirit and I wouldn’t want to. I try to shine a light.”

Gather: Surprising Stories and Other Mischief” opens at 8 p.m. Fri., May 24 in the Carrie Hamilton Theatre of the Pasadena Playhouse, 39 S. El Molino Ave., Pasadena. Tickets are $56. Call 626-356-7529 for more information. 

Start your day with Always Forward, our award-winning e-newsletter. Get this smart, handpicked selection of the day’s top news, analysis, and opinion, delivered to your inbox. Sign up absolutely free today!